# Standards matrix

> Status: research record, 2026-11-19. Versions and status were read from primary sources on that date and must be re-checked before implementation. "Use" is a council decision, not a claim of current conformance.

## Tool protocols

| Standard              | Version / date                                                                            | Status                                         | License                           | Requirement relevant to AI Auth                                                                                                           | Use decision                                                | Evidence                                                                  |
| --------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| MCP core              | 2026-07-28                                                                                | Released revision                              | MIT (spec/SDK)                    | Stateless; no `initialize`/`Mcp-Session-Id`; `server/discover`; `resultType`; per-request metadata; `tools/list` pagination; `tools/call` | Adopt as migration target, not in this milestone            | `modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/2026-07-28/`                       |
| MCP SDK (TypeScript)  | `@modelcontextprotocol/sdk` 1.32.2 (installed); 2.x split packages 2.4.0                  | Released                                       | MIT (1.x) / Apache-2.0 (2.x)      | Adapter must use the official SDK, not a hand-rolled JSON-RPC client                                                                      | Reuse; verify revision support before upgrade               | `packages/mcp/package.json`, npm registry                                 |
| MCP authorization     | OAuth 2.1 draft-13, RFC 9728, RFC 8707, RFC 8414, PKCE S256; DCR deprecated in 2026-07-28 | Normative when official HTTP framework is used | IETF                              | `Authorization: Bearer` on every request; servers MUST NOT accept tokens not issued for them                                              | Pass through untouched; never substitute AI Auth signatures | `modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/2026-07-28/basic/authorization.md` |
| MCP custom auth       | Base spec clause                                                                          | Allowed                                        | —                                 | Clients and servers MAY negotiate custom auth; it is not standard MCP authorization                                                       | Do not rely on it for interoperability                      | `specification/2026-07-28/basic.md`                                       |
| MCP HTTP+SSE          | 2024-11-05                                                                                | Deprecated                                     | MIT                               | Do not adopt for new work                                                                                                                 | Reject                                                      | 2026-07-28 changelog                                                      |
| WebMCP                | Draft Community Group Report, 13 Nov 2026                                                 | Draft, not W3C standard                        | W3C Software and Document License | `document.modelContext`, `registerTool`, `getTools`, `executeTool`, `toolchange`, registration `AbortSignal`                              | First-class provider with versioned compat adapter          | `webmachinelearning.github.io/webmcp/`                                    |
| WebMCP annotations    | Draft                                                                                     | Draft                                          | —                                 | `readOnlyHint`, `untrustedContentHint`, `consequentialHint`, `debugging`                                                                  | Already emitted by AI Auth (`CHANGELOG.md` 0.8.0)           | WebMCP draft IDL                                                          |
| WebMCP browser status | Chrome origin trial from 149; Edge 150 trial                                              | Experimental                                   | —                                 | Feature detect `'modelContext' in document`                                                                                               | Do not claim stable cross-browser support                   | `implementation-status.md`, Chrome docs                                   |
| UTCP spec             | 1.1 (1.2 in preparation)                                                                  | Published, RFC process                         | Apache-2.0 + MPL-2.0              | Manual, `tool_call_template`, direct native invocation, `${VAR}` secrets, `allowed_communication_protocols` defaults to own protocol      | First-class provider                                        | `utcp-specification/versions.json`                                        |
| UTCP TypeScript SDK   | `@utcp/sdk` 1.2.0, `@utcp/http` 1.1.14                                                    | Released                                       | MPL-2.0                           | `UtcpClient.create`, `registerManual`, `callTool`, `searchTools`, `getTools`; direct calls                                                | Reuse rather than rewrite                                   | npm registry, `typescript-utcp`                                           |
| UTCP–MCP bridge       | `@utcp/mcp-bridge` 1.1.0                                                                  | Released, low activity                         | MIT (package metadata)            | 7 meta-tools over `UtcpClient`; stdio; no OAuth                                                                                           | Reference code only, not a runtime dependency               | `utcp-mcp` repo                                                           |

## Identity, credentials and delegation

| Standard                 | Version / date             | Status                        | License                | Use decision                                                       | Evidence                             |
| ------------------------ | -------------------------- | ----------------------------- | ---------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ |
| AI Auth `agent:` id      | v0.11.1                    | Implemented                   | MIT                    | Keep canonical                                                     | `packages/p2p/index.js`              |
| RFC 7638 JWK thumbprint  | 2015                       | IETF Proposed Standard        | IETF                   | Reuse; already the basis of `identityFor`                          | `rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc7638`         |
| `did:key` alias          | Additive                   | Implemented                   | MIT                    | Keep additive; not an attestation                                  | `packages/p2p/did.js`, `docs/DID.md` |
| W3C DID Core             | Rec 19 Jul 2022            | W3C Recommendation            | W3C                    | Optional additive adapter only                                     | `w3.org/TR/did-core/`                |
| W3C VC Data Model        | 2.0, Rec 15 May 2025       | W3C Recommendation            | W3C                    | Defer; useful if an external verifier requires credentials         | `w3.org/TR/vc-data-model-2.0/`       |
| UCAN                     | 1.0.0                      | Community spec                | Community Spec License | Do not use as primary authorization; mandates DIDs, no confinement | `ucan-wg/spec`                       |
| Biscuit                  | v3.3                       | Apache-2.0, audit outstanding | Apache-2.0             | Defer; not a safe default for a security claim                     | `eclipse-biscuit/biscuit`            |
| OAuth 2.0 Token Exchange | RFC 8693, 2020             | IETF Proposed Standard        | IETF                   | Reuse where an external system requires delegation                 | `rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8693`         |
| DPoP                     | RFC 9449, 2023             | IETF Proposed Standard        | IETF                   | Reuse for sender-constrained tokens where required                 | `rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc9449`         |
| `panva/jose`             | 6.x                        | Released                      | MIT                    | Candidate for JOSE work; zero deps, WebCrypto-based                | `github.com/panva/jose`              |
| COSE                     | RFC 9052, STD 96           | Internet Standard             | IETF                   | Candidate where CBOR/COSE is required                              | `rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc9052`         |
| WebAuthn L2              | Rec 8 Apr 2021             | W3C Recommendation            | W3C                    | Optional hardware-key path; origin-scoped                          | `w3.org/TR/webauthn-2/`              |
| Post-quantum             | FIPS 203/204/205, Aug 2024 | Final NIST standards          | —                      | Keep algorithm identifiers pluggable; do not invent a scheme       | NIST announcement                    |

## Agent interoperability and commerce

| Standard                               | Version / date                       | Status                            | License    | Boundary decision                                          | Evidence                                                        |
| -------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | --------------------------------- | ---------- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------- |
| A2A                                    | 1.0.0                                | Released, Linux Foundation / AAIF | Apache-2.0 | Optional agent-communication adapter; do not recreate      | `a2aproject/A2A`, `a2a-protocol.org`                            |
| Agent Client Protocol                  | stable v1; v2 draft                  | Released                          | Apache-2.0 | Optional harness adapter; distinct from A2A                | `agentclientprotocol.com`                                       |
| IBM/BeeAI Agent Communication Protocol | archived 27 Aug 2025, v1.0.3         | Archived, merged into A2A         | Apache-2.0 | Do not revive; unrelated to ACP                            | `i-am-bee/acp`, ACP related-protocols page                      |
| UCP                                    | examples use 2026-08-25              | Active spec                       | Apache-2.0 | Separate commerce layer; ES256/Ed25519 JWK, RFC 7638 `kid` | `Universal-Commerce-Protocol/ucp`, `ucp.dev`                    |
| AP2                                    | v0.2.0, 28 Apr 2026                  | Pre-1.0, evolving                 | Apache-2.0 | Separate payment layer; mandates are not generic grants    | `google-agentic-commerce/AP2`                                   |
| UCP AP2 mandates extension             | `dev.ucp.common.payment.ap2_mandate` | Active extension                  | Apache-2.0 | Optional only; security-locked sessions cannot downgrade   | `ucp.dev/latest/specification/payment/extensions/ap2-mandates/` |

## Conformance status of this repository

| Item                                                  | Status                                                                                                     |
| ----------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| MCP tools/list + tools/call with SDK 1.32.2           | Implemented and tested (`packages/mcp/test/bridge.test.mjs`)                                               |
| MCP official OAuth authorization                      | **Not implemented**; local secret URL only                                                                 |
| MCP 2026-07-28 revision                               | **Not implemented**                                                                                        |
| WebMCP `document.modelContext` registration/discovery | Implemented and tested (`tests/webmcp-contract.test.mjs`)                                                  |
| WebMCP cross-origin three-gate policy                 | Native browser policy applies; no AI Auth-side emulation                                                   |
| UTCP adapter (optional subpath)                       | Implemented and tested with an injected client (`tests/utcp-adapter.test.mjs`); official SDK loaded lazily |
| Unified tool descriptor, registry and invocation API  | Implemented and tested (`tests/tool-registry.test.mjs`, `tests/unified-tools.test.mjs`)                    |
| Catalog converters for MCP, WebMCP and agent tools    | Implemented and tested (`tests/provider-adapters.test.mjs`)                                                |
| Optional Code Mode hardening                          | Implemented and tested (`packages/mcp/test/code-mode-hardening.test.mjs`)                                  |
| DID alias                                             | Implemented and tested (`tests/did.test.mjs`)                                                              |
| VC, UCAN, Biscuit                                     | **Not implemented**                                                                                        |
| A2A / ACP protocol classification boundary            | Implemented as additive helpers (`tests/agent-interop.test.mjs`); no task state or session semantics       |
| UCP / AP2 payment isolation boundary                  | Implemented as a deny-by-default guard (`tests/commerce-boundary.test.mjs`); no real mandates or payments  |
| Full A2A/ACP/UCP/AP2 protocol clients                 | **Not implemented**                                                                                        |

Every remaining "not implemented" row is a proposal, not a shipped capability. The UTCP adapter's own safety gates are tested; conformance against a live official SDK deployment is not claimed.
